South Cave Parish Council

 

Planning Meeting 12th March 2009

 

The Meeting of South Cave Parish Council Planning Committee took place in the Town Hall, Market Place, South Cave at 7.00pm.

 

Present:            Cllrs M Turner, Kelly, Manley, Harrison (Chairman), Lenton, Marsh, Barnett, and

                        Mrs K Richmond – Clerk

                        Ward Cllr Galbraith

                        Malte Kloeckner (ERYC Conservation Officer)

                       

           

1581  Apologies for absence

Cllr Manley proposed apologies be accepted from Cllr L Turner seconded Cllr Marsh, All in favour.

 

1582   Approval of Previous Meetings’ Minutes (9th February 2009)

Cllr Marsh proposed that the minutes of the previous meeting should be approved and accepted as a true record, seconded Cllr Lenton, All in favour.

 

1583   Declarations of Interest

There were no declarations of interest made at this point.

 

1584    Presentation

 Mr Malte Kloekner, Conservation Officer, East Riding of Yorkshire Council gave a brief presentation on the proposed amendments to the Conservation Area in South Cave. It was also suggested that Beverley Road be considered for inclusion. Any suggestions accordingly should be sent to Mr Kloekner.

 

1585   Correspondence

(i)Appeal by written representation – 07/05105/OUT, land south of 6-8 West Hall Garth, South Cave. Cllr Marsh proposed that a letter reiterating and expanding upon the Council’s concerns including the setting of a precedent, should be forwarded to the Planning Inspectorate, seconded Cllr Kelly, All in favour.

(ii)Appeal by written representation – 08/04207/PCC, demolition of two dwellings to allow for re-development of the site 21-23 West End, South Cave. Cllr Marsh proposed that as the Council raised no objection to the proposal, that no further comment be sent to the Planning Inspectorate, seconded Cllr Manley, All in favour.

(iii)Appeal by written representation – 08/04204/PLF, erection of two dwellings at 21-23 West End, South Cave Cllr Marsh proposed that as the Council raised no objection to the proposal, that no further comment be sent to the Planning Inspectorate, seconded Cllr Lenton, All in favour.

(iv)Appeal Decision – erection of two dwellings to the south of Netherwolds, Brough Road, South Cave – appeal dismissed. - Noted

            

1586           Decisions made by East Riding of Yorkshire Council

(i)DC/08/04187/PLF – 39 Beverley Road, South Cave – AWC (NObj)

(ii)DC/08/04679/PLF – Mt Airy Farm, South Cave – AWC (NObj)

(iii)DC/08/05653/PLF – 45 West End, South Cave – R (NObj)

(iv)DC/08/05591/PLF – 73 Market Place, South Cave – AWC (NObj)

 

 

Initialled..........

(v)DC/08/05678/PLF – 33 Wesley Close, South Cave – A1C (NObj)

 

 

1587 Current Plans to consider

(i)DC/09/00176/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Installation of 1 no. Air conditioning unit to rear at Alliance Pharmacy, 55 Market Place, South Cave for Boots UK  Cllr Lenton proposed that the Parish Council would raise no objection in principle as it has no adverse effect on the property or the street scene.  Consideration should be given to the addition of sound attenuation which will reduce the noise from 1 metre away from the unit to 50 decibels or less, to reduce the impact on neighbouring properties, seconded Cllr Barnett, All in favour.

Cllrs M Turner, Barnett and Harrison declared a personal interest in the following item.

(ii)DC/09/00250/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Change of use to form additional accommodation for existing dental surgery at 44 Church Street, South Cave for Mrs C Bolland (1 objection and 1 letter from the applicant received). Cllr Lenton proposed that the Parish Council would raise no objection in principal as it has no adverse effect on the property, the street scene, as there are no external alterations. If the LPA were minded to approve then we would suggest a condition that the property could only be used for the uses as outlined, such as staff training and amenity area, as an increase in surgery space may well increase the already difficult parking and traffic situation. We would also ask that clarification of the nature of the storage facility should also be obtained. The application has no adverse effect on the character and appearance of the Conservation Area, seconded Cllr Scott, vote:  6 in favour 1 against 1 abstention

Mr Rhynehart addressed the meeting in support of his application.

(iii)DC/09/00499/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of two storey extensions to front and side at 17 Bull Pasture, South Cave for Mr P Rhynehart.  Cllr Lenton proposed that as the application has no adverse effect on the property, neighbouring properties or the street scene, no objections be raised, seconded Cllr Marsh, All in favour.

(iv)DC/09/00583/PLF/WESTES – Conservation Area Consent

Demolition of existing dwelling and cartilage buildings at Castle View, Church Hill, South Cave for Cave Castle, South Cave. Cllr Lenton proposed that as there is a suitable replacement scheme, the Council raises no objection to the application. However, we would confirm that there is a historic stone plaque of some importance to the history of South Cave, and we request that this be retained either in the new building or erected in a prominent position in the village for public viewing, seconded Cllr Marsh, All in favour.

(v)DC/09/00584/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of replacement dwelling at Castle View, Church Hill, South Cave for Cave Castle, South Cave Cllr Scott proposed that the Parish Council raise no objection as it has no adverse effect on the neighbouring properties or the street scene, and as it is a replacement dwelling it should not increase the impact of traffic. We are pleased to see; the retention of the Ice House, as we believe this is listed; and the re-instatement of the wall. Would you also please note that there is a historic monument in the form of a plaque within the existing building, seconded Cllr Barnett, All in favour.

.

1588    Trees

            Cllr Scott declared a personal interest in the following item due to being a neighbour

            (i)App No. 6329 (S211) – prune a tree at 48 Church Street, South Cave Cllr Marsh proposed that the Parish Council raise no objection to the proposal on the grounds of good tree husbandry, seconded Cllr Kelly, All in favour.

 

 

Initialled..........

            (ii)Decision App No. 6261 – fell a tree at 14A Wesley Close, South Cave (replacement required) – Permission granted

            (iii)Decision App No. 6278 (S211) fell two trees at 44 West End, South Cave – permission granted

            (iv)To consider TPO on trees on ERYC land to the north of West End Farm Close. Cllr Lenton proposed that the tree survey that has now been updated be submitted to the LPA for them to consider a group TPO due to the quality and number of trees on site, seconded Cllr Manley, All in favour.

 

 

 

 

Signed…………………………

Chairman   

 

Dated…………………………..